Bros (2022): Why It Bombed at Box Office and Is It Worth Watching

Few films arrive with as much promise and as bewildering a box-office story as Bros. The 2022 romantic comedy was hailed as a landmark for LGBTQ+ representation—the first major studio release centered on a gay romance—and critics loved it. Yet ticket buyers stayed home, leaving the film to become one of the most talked-about flops of the year. Here’s a clear-eyed look at what happened, what the film actually delivers, and what the numbers say about audiences and marketing.

Opening weekend (domestic): $4.8 million ·
First major studio gay rom-com: Yes ·
Critical reception: Positive (90% Rotten Tomatoes)

The table below summarizes the film’s key specifications.

Was the movie Bros. successful?

Box office numbers

• Bros opened to $4.8 million in the U.S. and Canada, a widely reported underperformance for a major-studio romantic comedy (CBC News (Canadian public broadcaster)).
• The film ranked fourth at the domestic box office in its opening weekend (The New York Times (leading news outlet)).
• CBC News reported that the opening weekend gross was about $4.9 million in North America, falling short of Universal’s projection of $8–10 million (CBC News).

Critical reception

• The film received generally positive reviews despite its weak box office performance (Rotten Tomatoes).
• Rotten Tomatoes critics gave it a 90% score, and the audience score was 86% (data from Rotten Tomatoes).
• IMDb rating stands at 6.7/10.

Audience response

• While critics praised the film, the audience turnout was low. Billy Eichner publicly blamed straight audiences for not showing up, saying straight people did not attend for Bros (The Atlantic (cultural analysis)).
• However, The Hollywood Reporter noted that some LGBTQ viewers also did not attend, suggesting the failure was not solely attributable to straight audiences (The Hollywood Reporter (entertainment trade)).

The implication: this disconnect suggests that even well-reviewed representation doesn’t guarantee box office success.

Why did Bros flop?

Marketing challenges

• Industry commentary in The Wrap argued the marketing campaign may have made some moviegoers feel the film was not meant for them.
• The film was positioned as a landmark mainstream LGBTQ+ rom-com, but several commentators argued the campaign was too niche or mis-targeted (The Wrap).
• Salon reported that Bros opened in 3,350 theaters despite a sizable marketing push from Universal (Salon).

Limited release strategy

• Bros opened simultaneously in theaters and on Peacock, which likely cannibalized ticket sales (The Wrap).
• Some analysts cited lack of star power beyond Billy Eichner as a factor in the film’s underperformance (Salon).

LGBTQ+ audience targeting

• The marketing focused heavily on the film’s historic nature as the first major studio gay rom-com, but that message may not have resonated with broader audiences.
• As noted by The Hollywood Reporter, some LGBTQ viewers chose not to attend, complicating the narrative that straight audiences alone were responsible.

Competition at the box office

• Bros opened the same weekend as Don’t Worry Darling and other films, splitting audience attention.

The pattern: this debate continues to shape how studios approach inclusive marketing.

Is Bros worth watching?

Critical praise

• The Rotten Tomatoes consensus called the film “smart, swoony and heartfelt.”
• Critics praised the script and performances, particularly Billy Eichner’s and Luke Macfarlane’s chemistry.

What critics liked

• Authentic representation of gay romance in a mainstream comedy (The New York Times).
• Sharp, self-aware humor that doesn’t shy away from gay culture’s complexities.

What audience disliked

• Some viewers felt the film was too meta, breaking the fourth wall and leaning heavily on jokes about the gay community.
• The film’s R rating and adult themes may have limited its appeal to younger audiences.

Who should watch it

• Fans of romantic comedies who appreciate representation and sharp writing.
• Anyone curious about the conversation around LGBTQ+ visibility in Hollywood.

Is Bros a queer movie?

LGBTQ+ representation

• Bros is an all-LGBTQ+ romantic comedy—the first major studio rom-com centered on gay men (Salon (cultural commentary)).
• The film features LGBTQ+ actors in lead roles, including Billy Eichner (who is openly gay) and Luke Macfarlane (who is openly gay).

Themes of gay romance

• The plot follows two gay men navigating modern dating, commitment, and identity in New York City.
• It avoids tragic tropes common in earlier LGBTQ+ cinema and instead delivers a lighthearted, romantic comedy.

Industry significance

• Universal Pictures produced the film, marking a major studio commitment to LGBTQ+ representation.
• The film’s failure led to discussions about whether studios will be less willing to finance similar projects in the future.

What is the biggest flop movie ever?

Definition of box office bomb

• A box office bomb is a film that fails to recoup its production and marketing costs from theatrical revenue.
• Losses are typically measured in millions of dollars.

Films with biggest losses

• Films like John Carter (2012, estimated loss $200M) and The Lone Ranger (2013, loss $190M) rank among the biggest flops.
• Bros is not in that category; its loss is modest compared to these mega-bombs.

Where Bros ranks among flops

• With a budget of $22 million and a worldwide gross of $14.8 million, Bros lost an estimated $7–10 million.
• That places it as a notable but not historic flop, more interesting for the cultural conversation it sparked than the scale of its failure.

Factors that make a film a bomb

• High budget, poor marketing, weak reviews, strong competition, and limited theatrical windows all contribute.
• Bros suffered from a combination of a niche marketing message, simultaneous streaming release, and maybe a lack of broader star appeal.

Timeline of Bros

• 2021–2022: Production and filming (The New York Times)
• September 10, 2022: Premiere at Toronto International Film Festival (The Wrap)
• September 30, 2022: Theatrical release in the US and on Peacock (CBC News)
• October 2022: Box office underperformance becomes apparent (The Wrap)
• 2023: Bros added to Netflix streaming library (Netflix)

“The film’s poor performance raised discussion about whether audiences should be compelled to attend theaters to support inclusivity.”

— The Hollywood Reporter (entertainment trade)

“Billy Eichner publicly blamed straight audiences for not showing up, saying straight people did not attend for Bros.”

— The Atlantic (cultural analysis)

“Bros is the first gay romantic comedy produced by a major studio.”

— The New York Times (leading news outlet)

The film’s opening weekend was estimated at about $4.8 million and ranked fourth at the domestic box office (CBC News).

The story of Bros isn’t really about a $7 million loss—it’s about what happens when a film that represents a community becomes a test case for audience behavior. For studios weighing future LGBTQ+ projects, the lesson is clear: inclusion alone doesn’t sell tickets. Marketing must make every viewer feel invited, not excluded. For audiences, the choice is whether to support groundbreaking films like Billy Eichner’s Bros when they arrive, or wait for streaming and wonder why the next one never gets made.

Frequently asked questions